Potter Homes for Sale

Potter Homes for Sale

Welcome to Potter County, Pennsylvania, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Allegheny Plateau. Known for its breathtaking natural beauty and serene landscapes, Potter County offers a unique blend of outdoor adventure and small-town charm. With its rolling hills, lush forests, and pristine lakes, this region is perfect for nature enthusiasts, hikers, and anyone seeking a tranquil lifestyle away from the hustle and bustle of city life.

Potter County is rich in history and culture, boasting quaint towns like Coudersport and Galeton, where you can explore local shops, dine at cozy restaurants, and immerse yourself in community events. The county is also home to the stunning Cherry Springs State Park, famous for its dark skies, making it a prime location for stargazing and astronomy enthusiasts. Whether you enjoy fishing, hiking, or simply taking in the scenic views, Potter County has something for everyone.

For those considering a move to this idyllic area, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to different tastes and budgets. From charming cottages nestled in the woods to spacious family homes with expansive yards, Potter County's real estate market offers options that allow you to embrace the peaceful lifestyle this region is known for. Imagine waking up to the sound of chirping birds and sipping your morning coffee while surrounded by nature’s beauty.

Don’t miss the opportunity to explore the homes available in Potter County. Your dream home in this picturesque setting awaits! Embrace a life of tranquility and adventure in one of Pennsylvania’s most enchanting counties.

Newest Potter Homes for Sale

This property will be offered at Public Auction on Friday, August 21, 2026 @ 6pm. The listing price is the opening bid only and in no way reflects the final sale price. 10% down due at auction, 2% transfer tax to be paid by the purchaser, real estate taxes prorated. This 23-acre property, located just one mile outside of Shinglehouse Borough, is in a highly sought-after deer and turkey hunting area. Tucked away in a private setting, the property offers the perfect balance of seclusion and convenience, with fuel, groceries, a laundromat, local convenience stores, takeout restaurants, and access to local trails and back-country roads for side-by-side riding all nearby. Built in the summer of 2025, the cabin features an 8" block foundation, full 2x6 construction, fully insulated 6" walls, tongue-and-groove knotty pine interior, wiring for a small generator, a gated driveway, and an undeveloped spring. The layout includes an 8'x10' entryway/mudroom leading into a spacious 20'x24' open-concept living area with cathedral ceilings. Designed as a semi-off-the-grid hunting cabin, the structure is unfinished and does not include a bathroom, providing the opportunity for the next owner to complete it to fit their needs. Whether you're looking for a hunting retreat, recreational getaway, or private escape, this property offers an excellent opportunity in a desirable location.

675 Karr Hollow, Shinglehouse

Listing courtesy of Cavalry Realty LLC. Contact: (717) 932-2599

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Camp on Kettle Creek - 4 bedrooms ( 1 1st floor) , Great Room. 2 3/4 baths, Kitchen, living room & enclosed porch - State Forest on both sides, rear, Kettle Creek & then State Forest. Detached Garage. Seller is a PA licensed Realtor.

297 Chestnut Street, Cross Fork

Listing courtesy of Fish Real Estate, Inc.. Contact: (570) 893-4220

4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths

Welcome to a truly one-of-a-kind rural property offering two connected homes in a country setting with sweeping views and privacy. This versatile layout is ideal for multi-generational living, extended family, guest quarters, or income potential. Located near Denton Hill, the property is surrounded by ATV and outdoor recreation trails, close to State Game Lands, and situated under some of the darkest night skies in the region. Whether you're looking for a family compound, retreat or income property, this place delivers space, scenery and opportunity in a setting that's increasingly hard to find.

69 & 75 Sky Top Road, Coudersport

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX 1st Advantage. Contact: (717) 591-5555

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Come see this 4 BR - 2 Bath cabin on a full walk out basement with double doors that allows you to store all your toys safely inside. Located just outside Germania, Pa. just off Route 144 on a private 2.5 acre lot this home/cabin offers some of the best that Potter County has to offer. Located just across from the ATV and Snowmobile Trail systems this haven is centrally located to reach the entire trail system. Natural Gas heat and Tri County Hi Speed Internet gives you all of the comforts of home with the serenity of life in the woods. The inside space with cathedral ceiling and first floor bedroom and bath makes it feel larger than it appears plus the rear and front wrap around decks get you close to nature in Gods Country. Come grab this gem before she gets away.

4 Hemlock Ln, Galeton

Listing courtesy of Mountain Valley Realty Inc. Contact: 5707238484

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

List price is: $36,040. Built in 1968, this one level home offers approximately 1100 finished square feet, three bedrooms, one full bath, unfinished basement and sits on an approximate 69260 sqft (1.60 acre) lot. This home is in uninhabitable condition with many repairs noted.

68 Rt 44, Shinglehouse

Listing courtesy of RealHome Services and Solutions, Inc.. Contact:

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Songbird Lodge. Purchased as a Hunting Lodge and BNB but the owners decided to never rent it out, but enjoy the property instead. Sitting on almost twelve acres, the 2.5-story “farmhouse” is frame, with a stone front, log siding (front and sides) and vinyl siding at the rear of the house. The house is located approximately 900 feet from Short Run Road, which is open to four wheelers, the private lane is not open to four wheeler traffic, except for those with legal access to the lane. The structure sits over a crawl space which houses the well pump. Wood six panel doors! The first floor is open design, with a library, laundry, breakfast area, dining area, kitchen with gas range and dishwasher, living room, half bath and game room. Wood floors throughout most of the first floor, the main portion has ornate painted tin ceilings. The area is heated by a large vented propane space heater (had reportedly been a wood/coal stove), an unvented “fireplace” propane heater, a length of electric baseboard and a glass fireplace space heater. The ends have cathedral ceilings, wainscot and open area features. The second floor consists of a large suite with walk-in closet, and private bath; two bedrooms and a full bath. Floors are hardwood of varying woods plank sizes throughout the second floor. The bath has vinyl flooring. The third floor has carpeted floors. Two bedrooms and a loft area. Dormers provide a good view of the adjacent farm fields. Field views from the extended front porch, large deck (needs work), wild flowers, planted trees along lane, two large fields, large stands of pine trees tree house for hunting, sheds for four wheelers/mowers or livestock.

43 Songbird Way, Galeton

Listing courtesy of Mountain Valley Realty Inc. Contact: 5707238484

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Don't miss your chance to own this iconic country store located only 2 miles north of Cherry Springs State Park in Potter County. Originally known as Keeners Store the current owners are ready to retire and pass this awesome opportunity on to the next owners. The 3 acre property is turn key and in excellent condition. This country store is the only stop for miles along the highway to the stars on well traveled Route 44 and caters to the ever growing popularity of The Cherry Springs Dark Skies making this an extraordinary opportunity. Live onsite in the three bedroom upstairs suite while offering ice cream, subs, apparel, camping supplies, gasoline and so much more to the local camp owners, snowmobilers and the 100,000 plus visitors the State Park sees each year. A backup generator and new mechanicals in 2021 make this property very desirable.

4477 Cherry Springs Rd, Coudersport

Listing courtesy of Mountain Valley Realty Inc. Contact: 5707238484

Start Your Search